Bumble Bee Foods

Description

Jose Melena died when he was cooked alive inside an industrial oven called a 'retort.' Cal/OSHA found that Melena had entered the oven to make a repair or adjustment on a chain inside the machine. He left a pallet jack he used to load the tuna into the oven outside of the oven. Another employee saw that the pallet jack was not being used and assumed that Melena was in the bathroom, so the employee proceeded to use the pallet jack. A supervisor noticed the employee was using Melena's pallet jack and asked where he was, prompting an announcement over the intercom and a search of the plant. After searching for about an hour and a half, an employee suggested looking in the last oven that had been loaded, which is where they found Melena's body. The company did not have Lockout/Tagout procedures requiring the equipment to be turned off with an employee inside or provide an escape route or a spotter to keep watch with a worker in a confined space.

Prosecutors:
Deputy District Attorney Christopher Curtis; Consumer Protection Division Assistant Head Deputy Hoon Chun
Incident Type: Caught in Machine
County: Los Angeles
State: CA
Date: Oct. 11, 2012
Additional Materials
Folder for Bumble Bee Foods materials
Available Case Materials Include:
Media Clips & Gov't. Press
OSHA inspection detail OSHA inspection detail OSHA inspection detail
Contact for Additional Information:
Unavailable
Victims
First Last Age Title Employer Injury Type
Jose Melena 62 Unavailable Bumble Bee Foods Fatality
Defendants
Name Type Title Plea Info. Conviction Sentence
Saul Florez Individual Safety Manager Pleaded guilty to 1 felony count of labor violation causing a workers death Sentenced to 3 years of formal probation and mandatory 30 day community labor and work-safety classes on LOTO and confined spaces. He must also pay $19,000 in fines and penatlies. If he has complied with the plea agreement in 18 months, he may be eligible to have the felony conviction reduced to a misdemeanor. Must make a public statement admitting guilt for role in the death.
Crimes Charged: Penal Crimes: None
Other Crimes: Labor Code violation causing death to an employee (Cal. Lab. Code Sec. 6425)
Angel Rodriguez Individual Director of Plant Operations Pleaded guilty Mandatory 320 hours of community service, $11,400 in fines and penalties, and classes on LOTO and confined spaces. If he complies, he may be allowed to plead guilty to a misdemeanor instead of a felony at sentencing. Must make a public statement admitting guilt for their roles in the death.
Crimes Charged: Penal Crimes: None
Other Crimes: Labor Code violation causing death to an employee (Cal. Lab. Code Sec. 6425)
Bumble Bee Foods Entity Entity Settled Settled for $6 million fine for willfully violating worker safety rules causing a workers death. The terms require the company to complete certain safety measures (e.g., $3 million upgrade to ovens, training). The family will also receive $1.5 million in restitution. $750,000 will go to the DA's Environmental Enforcement Fund. The company will also pay a combined $750,000 in fines, penalties, and court costs. Under the terms of the agreement entered into in August 2015, it was not formally imposed for 18 months after entered into. At the end of the 18 months, if the company complied with the settlement terms, it was permitted to plead guilty to a misdemeanor count of willful failure to implement and maintain an effective safety program.
Crimes Charged: Penal Crimes: None
Other Crimes: Labor Code violation causing death to an employee (Cal. Lab. Code Sec. 6425)